The Deckhand Was Shouted Down for Stealing the Catch Until the Auctioneer Played the Captain's Own Voice
Captain Lonnie Broussard had T-Boy Thibodeaux by the shirt collar in front of forty buyers, and his voice carried all the way to the scale house. "Where's my catch money?" T-Boy didn't pull away. He'd worked twenty-two seasons on that dock, and he knew exactly what he'd written in his log at two o'clock that morning.
Lonnie owns the boat, the co-op account, and the landing tickets. He decides whether T-Boy eats this winter. And now, in front of every buyer on the bayou, he was calling him a thief.
Two deckhands took T-Boy by the arms and walked him off the boards. Lonnie told him he was done — no more day work, no more dock, no more nothing.
Mavis Fontenot had been auctioneering that harbor for forty-one years. She had seen captains yell at deckhands before. She had never once stepped out of her booth for it. She stepped out for this one.
She came through the auction shed door carrying a scuffed cassette player, the kind nobody had used in a decade, and set it down flat on the scale-house rail. Calm. Deliberate. She looked at Lonnie and said, "Before you say one more word about that man, I want you to hear your own voice."
The crowd went quiet. Lonnie laughed. He actually laughed.
"Play whatever you want, Mavis. I ain't got nothing to hide."
She pressed play.
For a second there was nothing but hiss and the low hum of a boat engine. Then a voice came out of the harbor PA speaker — clear, easy, familiar. Lonnie's own voice. Nobody on that dock could mistake it.
"...yeah, we already sold that load to Guidry this morning, but I've got near about the same weight in the tank, I'll give it to you at six-fifty a pound if you take it off me before the co-op weighs in..."
The whole harbor heard it. Forty buyers. The scale house. The boys on the ice tubs. Lonnie's grip on T-Boy's collar went slack.
Two men at the nearest tailgate set their foam coffee cups down at the same time. Nobody picked them back up.
Mavis lifted the player higher over the rail so the sound carried. Lonnie turned toward the speaker with his mouth open, and for a few seconds he just stood there, listening to himself. Listening to something he had said years ago, in a wheelhouse, when he thought no one was holding a tape.
T-Boy didn't move. He didn't smile. Twenty-two seasons of numbers were already running through his head — every ticket, every pound, every morning he'd written the ice down while the captain slept.
He walked to the nearest truck, laid his ice-tank log flat on the tailgate, and opened it to the page he had known by heart for five years. His stub pencil was still behind his ear. He used the tip of it to hold the page down.
"There," he said, to no one and everybody. "Two o'clock in the morning. Ice machine off. L.B. That's your hand on my page, Captain. That's your own initials."
Lonnie stared at the log. He stared at the cassette player. Then he said the thing that made every man on that dock understand something had gone wrong a long time before this morning.
"That tape ain't from me. I never recorded myself."
Mavis didn't answer him. She didn't look at him either. She was looking at the cassette itself — the paper label, the way the grease pencil was written across it. Not in a captain's hand. In a deckhand's hand. In handwriting she had seen on landing tickets for years.
T-Boy saw it too. His face changed in a way the buyers would talk about for weeks. His hand came up and touched the brass compass in his front pocket. His brother's compass. The one Clovis always carried.
Five years ago. The night the ice machine failed. The night Clovis went over the side of the F/V Séréna and Lonnie brought the boat in alone and called it a fall.
The tape was still turning. Lonnie's voice had finished.
Mavis reached up and stopped the player with one finger.
"What's on the rest of it?" Lonnie said. His voice had gone thin. "Mavis. What's on the rest of it."
Mavis Fontenot looked at him for a long moment, and then she did the thing that made the whole dock lean forward. She rewound the tape. She lifted it out of the player. She put it back in her apron pocket. And she said she'd hold onto it until the co-op board sat.
The deputies came the following Saturday. The co-op read the revocation aloud over that same PA. T-Boy signed the boat's title over to his nephew Remy at the auction table while Mavis watched.
But that tape — the last ten minutes of it — was never played out loud on the dock. Mavis never explained why. The co-op attorney listened to it alone in the scale house with the door closed, and when he came out he was white as a sheet and wouldn't answer a single question.
The parish reopened the file on Clovis Thibodeaux the next morning. Five years of "accidental fall" came off the paperwork in one afternoon. Nobody knows yet what was on the end of that tape, or why the auctioneer who kept it almost played the whole thing and then changed her mind.
Neither does T-Boy. Not yet.
Follow the link below — the full story picks up on that deck the following week, when Mavis finally takes the cassette out of her pocket and tells T-Boy the truth about what his brother said before the water took him.
Advertisement