Chapter 5
Story: She Called My Bakery a Rented Place, Then I Set the Contract's Second Page on the Counter
Dana Whitfield had been Barb's friend for thirty years.
I knew that because Barb had told me, once, in the kitchen of the house I had shared with Ken for the first five years of our marriage. Dana had been there at the wedding. Dana had been there at the anniversary parties. Dana had been the one who stood next to Barb in the courthouse hallway on the day of the divorce, holding her arm, nodding at the right moments.
I had always thought Dana was Barb's friend.
Standing in my bakery on a Saturday afternoon, watching Dana set the manila folder on the counter and open it, I understood that I had been wrong.
"I was the one who told her to flip the page," Dana said, and her voice was flat, level, carrying nothing at all. "She read the clause, stood up, and laughed. She said —"
"We don't need to do this here," Barb said. Her voice had gone sharp, cutting, in the tone she used when she wanted to stop a conversation before it started.
"I think we do," Dana said. And then, to the room — to Ken, to me, to the shopper with the phone: "She said, and I quote: 'I'll have her building and her business by the end of the summer.'"
Ken's face had not resolved into any expression at all. He stood behind the boxes with his hands hanging at his sides, watching his mother, and I could see him trying to find a version of the last five minutes that made sense, that fit what he thought he knew.
"Page two," Dana went on. "The cancellation-and-ownership clause. If the buyer publicly claims the vendor has no permanent premises, the deposit converts to a purchase option on the buyer's catering company share."
"The catering company I already sold," Ken said. His voice was not a question.
"Greg's not the issue," Dana said. "The share was yours at the time of the contract. You signed as part of the catering company. When Barb converted the deposit, the option attached to the share — your share, before you sold it. The option has a window. Thi exercised it today."
Barb made a sound. Not a word, just a sound — a small, sharp exhale, like something had broken inside her chest.
"You can't," she said. "That share is Ken's. It was Ken's. I signed as —"
"As buyer," Dana said. "On behalf of the catering company. Which you'd done a dozen times. That's why the clause worked."
I looked at the manila folder on the counter. Dana pushed it toward me.
"Copy of the contract, signed at the planning meeting, February 12th," she said. "Barb's signature, page two. My initials on every clause. I didn't notarize it, but —"
"You initialed every clause?" I asked.
"I initialed every clause," Dana said. "I wanted to be able to say I'd seen it."
The room was quiet. The pastry-case hum. A car on the lot outside. The shopper's phone, steady, recording.
"Mom," Ken said.
Barb did not look at him. She was looking at Dana with the expression of a woman who had just realized that the person she trusted with her accounts had been keeping a separate ledger for decades.
"Why?" Barb asked.
Dana looked at her for a long moment.
"Because you asked me to," she said. "Thirty years ago. At your son's wedding. Remember? We were standing in the kitchen and you said to me: 'I need someone who will tell me the truth even when I don't want to hear it.'"
Barb's mouth opened.
"You asked for that," Dana said. "You got it. You just didn't think I meant it." And she looked at me — flat, level, tired. "I've been keeping copies of Barb's contracts for eleven years. I've watched her do this to other people. I've watched her do it to you." A pause. "I had a list of who she'd done it to if you ever needed it."
I did not ask the question. I did not say the thank-you. I just looked at the folder on the counter, at the contract with Dana's initials climbing the margin like a ladder.
"The proof has actually been lying in that folder for eleven years," I said. "Kevin, I know that's what you're thinking. I'm not saying it to be mean. I'm saying it so you understand: Barb has been —"
On the counter, the order contract had been lying among the cupcake trays, page two facing the light, under a smear of frosting. I flicked a crumb off the paper where Dana's initials lined the margin, and looked at Dana.
"February 12th," I said. "That's the date the party was planned? I thought you had the contract in August."
"I had the August contract," Dana said. "This is the second one. Barb's been a repeat customer."
I looked at Barb. She was standing very straight, very still, her face white under the makeup, her hand gripping her purse strap as the room filled with the sound of the pastry-case hum.
"You signed a second contract," I said.
No answer.
"You planned this," I said. "You waited for me to slip. You told Dana that page two was the one that mattered. You read the clause yourself and then you came here, to my bakery, in front of a customer with a phone —"
"Thi," Barb said, and her voice came out quiet, pitched low, almost gentle, which was more frightening than the soprano had been. "Let's talk about what you want."
I looked at her.
"Because we both know," she said, "that this is about money. You want to hurt Ken. You want to hurt this family. And that's fine. That's your right. But I want you to think about what happens next. I have friends. I have attorneys. I have —"
"Go ahead," Dana said.
Barb stopped.
"I'm telling you," she said, "I have a very good lawyer."
"I know," Dana said. "You've introduced me to him. Twice. Both times when I was the one you wanted to sue." She picked up her folder, tucked it back under her arm. "He's good. He's not a miracle worker. He can't make a signed clause disappear."
Advertisement