Chapter 2
Story: The Chief Named Her a Thief at the Banquet — Then a Supplier Opened a Binder Nobody Had Asked For
"Del signed for it," Marta Reyes said, and her voice cut through the murmuring like a blade. She wasn't looking at the podium anymore. She was looking at the delivery confirmation with her reading glasses down on her nose, and her finger was tracing the signature like she was checking the handwriting of someone she'd known for thirty years. "That's Del's hand. I've seen Del sign for freight at his feed store a hundred times. That's his hand."
Dwayne Kohler turned his wedding band on his finger, a full rotation this time, slow. "Del signed for a delivery," he said, and his voice was starting to lose the slow rumble, starting to climb in pitch. "That's not a crime. That's my brother helping me accept a shipment because I was at a structure fire that day. You want to tell me that's a crime?"
Owen Pace didn't take the bait. He was still standing beside the head table, tall and stooped, both hands resting on the open binder, and he looked at Dwayne the way a man looks at a fence he's already climbed. "I don't tell anybody what's a crime," he said, dry. "I write down what happened. I got a photo."
He pulled the whiteboard away from the podium leg before anybody could stop him—a plain whiteboard, the kind used for drills, with a marker clipped to the frame—and he set it up against the head table, facing the room. Then he picked up the black marker and wrote, in block letters, big enough for the back row, three sets of numbers.
S/N 44719-A
S/N 44720-A
S/N 44721-A
"Serial numbers," Owen said, tapping each line with the marker cap. "They're on every SCBA bottle I sell, stamped into the metal collar, hard to miss if you're looking." He reached into the binder's front pocket and pulled out a photograph, printed on plain paper, a little creased, and held it up so the whole room could see it. "Three bottles, bolted to the bed of a truck, taken in a gravel lot, forty minutes ago, sir."
He said the word sir the way a man says a word at the end of a long rope.
"Sixty feet from these doors," he added. "Parked in the county lot. Truck doesn't belong to this department—I checked the plates, and the plates don't match any vehicle registered to the department or to any fire district in this county."
The chairs started to shift. A woman at table two stood up, craning to see the photo, and then sat back down. A man at table seven pushed his plate away. Somebody in the back said, "Is that the truck that's been parked out there since before the potluck?" and somebody else said, "I thought it was somebody's cousin."
Jenna was still at table nine, hands flat on the paper cloth. Her satchel was still hooked on her chair. She watched Owen Pace hold the photo up, and she watched the serial numbers on the whiteboard, and she watched Marta Reyes stand up from the head table, walk over to Owen, and take the photo out of his hand so gently that it might have been a bird.
Marta held the photo up to the light. She turned it slightly. She looked at the bottles, at the truck bed, at the gravel lot in the background, and then she looked at the whiteboard, and then she looked at the carbon copy on the head table, and then she looked at Dwayne Kohler.
"The serials match," she said, and her voice was flat and quiet and carried exactly as far as it needed to. "These numbers on the board, they match the numbers on the bottles in this photo."
The hall went quiet in a way that had teeth in it.
Dwayne Kohler had been standing at the podium with one hand flat on the plastic banner the whole time, and now he took a step back, an actual step, like somebody had pushed him. He looked at the photo in Marta's hand. He looked at the carbon copy with D.K. in blue ink. He looked at the whiteboard, and his jaw worked once, side to side, like he was chewing something that hadn't been cooked.
"That truck," he said, and stopped. Cleared his throat. "That truck is—that's a loaner. From a salvage outfit. They're checking them over before they're sold."
"They're bolted to the bed," Owen Pace said, patient, unhurried, like he was explaining something to a customer who wasn't ready to buy. "Anybody who takes them off is going to need a socket set and time. Those are my bottles, from my order, and they were signed for at your brother's barn eleven months ago, and they ended up in a gravel lot in a truck that's not registered to this department." He paused. "That's the whole story, chief. That's all of it."
The room did the math again, a third time, and this time there were a lot of different ways to do that math, and none of them came out in Dwayne Kohler's favor.
Nobody said thief. Nobody said it out loud. But Jenna watched the faces around her turn, slowly, from the podium to the whiteboard to the photo in Marta's hand, and she watched the same expression arrive on all of them, one after another, like a wave moving across water.
Marta Reyes put the photo down on the head table, flat, face up, so everyone could see it. She took her reading glasses off her forehead and folded them, and she looked at Dwayne Kohler with the calm, careful expression of a woman who has just watched the ground shift under her feet and decided she doesn't like the new ground, either.
"Chief," she said, "who was at the fundraiser? Who counted the cash at the summer fundraiser?"
"I already said—" Dwayne started.
"No, I know what you said. You said Jenna counted it." Marta tapped the bank statement still sitting on the head table, the second copy, the treasurer's copy, the one she'd been frowning at since before Owen walked in. "But this statement here, the one the treasurer printed tonight, it says the deposit happened on the nineteenth, three days after the fundraiser. It doesn't say cash on the deposit line. It says check, and a check number, and the total doesn't match the fundraiser total." She looked up at Dwayne, and her voice was quiet and flat. "I've been sitting here all night trying to figure out why that line didn't sit right. You read a bank statement out loud and named her a thief, but this statement says the deposit was a check, not cash. So where did the cash go before it got deposited, and who made the deposit?"
The room was completely silent. Jenna could hear the fluorescent lights humming over the folding tables, the sound of somebody's fork setting down on a paper plate, the soft squeak of a chair as somebody leaned forward to watch.
Dwayne Kohler stood at the podium, and for a long moment he said nothing. His hand was still on the plastic banner, and his wedding band was turning on his finger, one rotation, two, three, fast now, like a man winding a watch.
"I'm suspending the investigation," he said finally. "Until I've had a chance to review—"
"You can't suspend an investigation that was never opened," Marta said, and she said it into the quiet like a woman setting down a heavy thing. "You made an accusation in front of the whole department. There's no investigation to suspend. There's just a room full of people who watched you point a finger at a firefighter with a carbon copy and a delivery confirmation sitting on a table saying it was you who wrote the initials."
Somebody at the back of the room—Jenna didn't see who, couldn't see who, was still looking at her hands—said, quiet but clear, "Read the receiving page."
And then another voice, from the other side: "Where's the receiving page for that year?"
And then a third: "The binder's missing the receiving page. The one with the supply logs. I looked for a screwdriver tonight and it's gone."
Marta turned to the treasurer's table, where a stack of department binders sat beside the sign-in sheet. She walked over, picked up the binder for the department records from last year, and opened it. She flipped through the pages once, twice, and then she held the binder up, open, so the whole room could see the empty rings where a page had been torn out.
Nobody said anything. Nobody needed to.
Dwayne Kohler's jaw stopped moving, and his eyes dropped to the statement on the head table, and for the first time in the whole night, he didn't look like a chief. He looked like a man standing on a floor that had just been pulled out from under him, and he didn't have anywhere left to put his feet.
Advertisement