Chapter 8
She stood on the porch step with a small paper bag in her hand and did not knock for a full minute.
Arlene saw her through the kitchen window. She was at the sink, washing the last of the morning dishes, and she saw the shape of a tall woman in a plain gray jacket come up the gravel lane and stop at the bottom of the wooden steps. She did not put the dish down. She dried her hands, took off her apron, folded it, set it on the counter, and walked to the door.
She opened it.
"Hello, Marlene," she said.
"Hello, Arlene."
They stood there for a moment. Marlene looked older than she had looked three weeks ago. Her hair was pulled back and there was gray at her temples that Arlene had never noticed before, and her hands were bare and her nails were unpainted, and her eyes were red-rimmed in a way that had nothing to do with crying and everything to do with not sleeping.
"I brought you something," Marlene said. She held out the paper bag. "It's not a gift. It's just something of yours that I have."
Arlene took the bag. She opened it. Inside was a small brass plaque, six inches by four, the same shape and size as the bottom corner of the kitchen plaque had been. It had two screw holes in it and it had been cleaned of paint.
It was the original corner. The corner from before 2022, when the parish had first hung the plaque after the kitchen addition was completed. It was the piece Marlene had removed in October two years ago so that she could paint over the letters on the main plaque without leaving an obviously crooked line.
The letters on it were the same as the plaque on the wall. WALTER KASPAREK, 1998.
"You kept it," Arlene said.
"I kept it," Marlene said. "I don't know why. I could have thrown it away. I could have dropped it in the Badger Creek. I put it in my glove box and it stayed there for two years. I think about it every time I drive the car."
"Why are you bringing it to me now?"
Marlene looked at the porch boards. Then she looked up.
"Because it belongs to you," she said. "And because I wanted to say something to you in person before I said it to anybody else in this town."
Arlene waited.
"I'm not going to ask you to forgive me," Marlene said. "You already did that in the hall and I heard it and I don't deserve it and I'm not going to pretend I do. I'm not going to ask the parish to forgive me either. I don't want to be forgiven. I want to make of this what I can. The diocese has notified me I'll be making restitution to the parish over a period of years. The county attorney has notified me that there may be charges. I don't know yet what that will look like. My husband has moved out. He went to his brother's place in St. Cloud. He hasn't said a word to me about any of this and he doesn't have to because there isn't a word he could say that would make any difference now."
She paused.
"I wanted you to know that I did it," she said. "Every bit of it. I painted over Walter's name in 2022 because I was afraid the parish would find out that I had lied about the kitchen addition in the anniversary history. I spent the second bequest on the church's regular bills because I told the council in 1999 that it had never arrived, and once I had told that lie I could not untell it, and the only way to keep it was to spend the money on things that looked legitimate. I started writing small catering invoices to myself eight years ago because the church's budget was tight and I told myself I was entitled to be paid for the work I did at every event, and then eight years later the little invoices were big ones and there was no way back. I told the parish on Sunday that you were the thief because I had spent three days before that Sunday looking at the account and seeing that the hole was going to show up in the audit, and I needed the money to already be missing from somewhere that wasn't me."
She stopped.
"That's all of it," she said. "That's every dollar and every lie."
Arlene stood in the doorway with the paper bag in her hand.
"Do you want to come in?" she said.
Marlene blinked.
"Why?"
"Because I have coffee on," Arlene said. "Because you drove out here on a wet Friday morning with a brass plaque in a paper bag, and you stood on my porch for a full minute before you knocked, and I could hear you breathing from the kitchen. Because I have spent twenty-six years being the quiet one and I know how much it costs to knock."
Marlene did not move.
"I'm not going to sit at your table with your husband's name over it," she said.
"Then we'll sit in the living room."
"I'm not going to sit in your living room under your wedding picture."
"We'll sit on the porch," Arlene said. "It's forty degrees and the wind is from the west and the coffee will get cold in five minutes. But you drove forty minutes to get here and I'm not going to stand in my own doorway while you drive forty minutes back without a cup of coffee in you, because that is not how I was raised and my husband was raised the same way and if we don't do that much for the person who took our money, we are the ones who are lost."
Marlene stood there.
Then she sat down on the porch step, slowly, and put her hands on her knees.
Arlene went inside, poured two cups of coffee, and came back out. She handed one cup to Marlene and sat down on the top step above her, so they were on the same staircase but not the same step, and the wind came in from the west and moved the muddy yard around and the maple buds shook overhead.
They sat like that for a while.
"I don't have anything to say to you," Marlene said finally. "I came here not knowing what to say and I drove forty minutes not knowing what to say, and I still don't."
"Then don't say anything," Arlene said.
"Do you hate me?"
Arlene considered that.
"No," she said. "I don't hate you. I did for about an hour on Sunday in the hall. Then I didn't. Hatred is a lot of work and I'm sixty-three and I've got a kitchen to clean. What I have is just the ground where the hate would have been, and I don't know what to put there yet."
Marlene nodded.
"I'm going to move," she said. "Not right away. But at the end of the summer. I don't think I can sit in that church anymore. Not because the parish is angry at me. Because when I sit in that church I see the kitchen and I see the plaque and I see the door I walked out of and I can't get up from the pew."
"I know," Arlene said. "I sat in that church for twenty-six years with a drawer in my china cabinet that I never opened. Do you know what finally got me to open it? A bishop who said my husband's name in a hall full of people. Not because he was trying to help me. Because he remembered a letter from 1998 and a check and my husband's signature, and my husband mattered to someone I'd never met. That's what got me to open the drawer."
She took a sip of coffee.
"You don't have to move," she said. "But if you do, I understand."
They sat together for another twenty minutes without saying much. When Marlene finished her coffee, she stood up and put the cup on the porch railing, and she said, "Thank you for the coffee," and Arlene said, "Thank you for the plaque," and Marlene walked down the gravel lane to her car and drove away.
Arlene went inside and put the new old corner of the plaque in her china cabinet drawer, on top of the letter, so that they were kept together. She did not know yet what to do with it. She thought perhaps she would ask Herb to install it back onto the kitchen plaque on the wall at church, on the original screw holes, so that the plaque would be one piece of brass again with Walter's name on it from top to bottom, and so that in another twenty-five years somebody would find it that way.
The bishop had asked her, on Sunday, at the very end, whether she had any last question. Arlene had thought about it and had said no. But driving home from the parking lot she had thought of one, and she had written it down on the back of a grocery receipt, and she had put the receipt in her purse.
The question was: Walter gave the money for a school. The school was never built. If the money was never going to be spent on the school, why did he give it at all?
She knew the answer now, mostly. She knew it when she'd read the letter in the drawer and read the check stub and stood at the bank with her husband's wallet in her hand. Her husband had given the money because he believed in the school. He had given it because his mother had worked for the creamery for thirty-five years so that the children of Badger Creek could go to a Catholic school, and he had kept that in his heart for his whole life, and he had given it away without telling her because he wanted to spare her the burden of being known as the woman whose husband had given away everything his mother saved.
She went to the kitchen and stood at the window and looked at the fields going green and the mud ruts drying in the lane, and she thought about how much of her life had been lived in rooms that other people had decided things for, and how one Sunday, out of nowhere, a bishop had walked through a door and said her husband's name in a hall full of people with hot dishes on the folding tables, and the paint had come off the plaque under her thumb, and everything had changed in eleven seconds.
She went to the china cabinet and opened the drawer one last time, and read the letter one last time, and tucked it back into the envelope, and put the envelope away with the brass corner plate underneath it. Then she closed the drawer and went to the sink and finished washing the morning dishes and dried her hands and put her apron back on. Tuesday was cleaning day at St. Casimir's, same as every week, and she had a hall to set up and a linoleum to mop and a coffee urn to get going before the first of the confirmation mothers arrived for the volunteers' meeting at eleven.
She drove in at ten-fifteen in her old car with the tool belt still in the trunk. She parked in her spot and walked in through the kitchen door. The plaque was on the wall beside the door where it had always been, but Walter's name was fully clean now and the frame was polished, and a small brass plate hung under it: "The Walter Kasparek Kitchen. Dedicated in gratitude, 2024."
She stood in front of it for a moment.
Then she tied on her apron and filled the first coffee urns and laid out the cups and put the folding chairs in rows for the volunteers' meeting and wrote the stipend schedule on the whiteboard by the kitchen door so that the new volunteers could see exactly what they'd be paid and when.
At eleven o'clock, four women came in to be trained for the new schedule. One was Nadine. One was Corinne. One was the young woman from the card. And one, walking in with her coat over her arm, taking a chair on the far side of the folding table and sitting down quietly without looking anyone in the eye, was a woman none of the others had expected to see, and nobody said a word about it, and Arlene poured her a cup of coffee and set it in front of her and put the stipend clipboard in her hands, and went on with the meeting.
The kitchen was hers now, in the way that mattered. It had always been hers in the way that mattered. The plaque on the wall said so, and had said so under the paint since 1998, and would say so for as long as the building stood.
Advertisement